Taylor Swift Rocks a Little Black Dress for Girls Night with Cara Delevingne and Brittany Mahomes

The trio were most recently seen together at the Chiefs’ victory over the Bills Sunday

Taylor Swift is hitting the town with her besties!

The pop star, 34, was spotted enjoying a night out in New York City with Cara Delevingne and Brittany Mahomes on Tuesday dressed in a sophisticated, loose-fitting little black dress.

The long-sleeved dress was accessorized with a gold chain belt, leather boots, and a small handbag. She wore a pair of earrings from Mazin Jewelry (a recent fave brand!) added a pop of color by wearing bright pink nail polish.

Like Swift, Delevingne, 31, was also dressed in black. Mahomes, 28, opted for a checked blazer and mini skirt paired with black boots and a white handbag.

The outing came days after the trio cheered on the Kansas City Chiefs during their victory against the Buffalo Bills in Highmark Stadium.

Apart from winning 27-24 and advancing to the AFC Championship against the Baltimore Ravens on Jan. 28, the game was also one to remember since Swift and Mahomes’ respective partners broke a new record.

During the game, Travis Kelce, Swift’s boyfriend, caught two touchdown passes from Mahomes’ husband, quarterback Patrick Mahomes.

The passes gave Kelce, 34, and Patrick, 28, the record for the most post-season touchdowns by a pair in NFL history, a mark previously held by New England Patriots duo Tom Brady and Rob Gronkowski.

Swift wore her signature red lip, matching beanie, and a retro-styled jacket from the GANT x Kilo Kish Blank Canvas Project collaboration at the game.

Mahomes paired a puffer jacket emblazoned with her husband’s “15” jersey number with pants stitched with “MAHOMES” on the right pant leg. The all-red outfit was topped off with a Chanel purse. Delavigne kept her game-day outfit casual by wearing a white t-shirt, black pants, and a gray coat.

She shared photos from the game on Instagram that included Kylie Kelce, Travis’ sister-in-law. Also on hand to support the Chiefs tight end was his brother Jason and their parents, Donna and Ed Kelce.

Buffalo Bills season ticket holder Matt C. sat below the group’s suite and told PEOPLE it was something he and his son Colin would never forget.

“We get to the games relatively early and we noticed a sizable police presence right behind our seats. We usually talk to the people in the suites behind us, so, of course, we peeked through the window, and there was Taylor Swift,” he told PEOPLE.

Despite the cold temperatures, Matt said the suite window was kept open throughout the game.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

“There was definitely some banter between the Kelce/Swift suite and the fans below – especially when points were scored. In the end, they won and have the bragging rights,” he added.